Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

California School Fiscal Services

Providing comprehensive business office and consulting services to K-12 traditional schools and charters



Important Case Decision flies under the radar while we were focused on Vergara, -- could drastically impact school district employee evaluations- Author: Jackie McHaney

Posted on August 1, 2014 at 2:25 PM

With all of our attention recently focused on the outcome of the Vergara decision, the recent Court of Appeal decision in Poole v. Orange County Fire Authority (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 155, flew so low under the radar that it almost went unnoticed.


In Poole, Steve Poole was a firefighter with the Orange County Fire Authority (Fire Authority) from 2008 to 2010. As part of the evaluation process, Poole’s supervisor had a practice of maintaining daily logs on a flash drive and in a folder kept at his desk, to enable him to refresh his memory and assist him in preparing written evaluations. Poole’s supervisor asserted that the daily logs included the recording of “any factual occurrence or occurrences that would aid … in writing a thorough and fair annual review.” In the case at bar, it was determined that Poole’s supervisor made over one hundred handwritten and computerized notes, which documented the efficiency of Poole as well as other firefighters in the department, in carrying out their duties. In 2009, Poole’s supervisor, relying largely on his daily logs to aid in the preparation of the written evaluation, issued Poole a substandard evaluation because his “work habits, personal relations, adaptability, and progress were unsatisfactory.” As a result of this substandard evaluation, Poole was placed on a performance improvement plan.


Unsatisfied with his substandard evaluation, Poole (with the assistance of his union) sought copies of the daily logs, which included more than 100 entries regarding Poole, many of which described areas in need of improvement. Poole was provided copies of these documents. Upon receipt of these documents, Poole requested that all adverse comments in the daily logs be removed because he never had any opportunity to respond prior to their use for personnel purposes in his performance evaluation and subsequent improvement plan. The Fire Authority refused to remove the comments, contending that, even though the notes were for personnel purposes, they were never “entered” into any file used for personnel purposes. Rather, the Fire Authority contended that Poole had the opportunity to respond to the comments in the evaluation, which would be placed in the personnel file.


Poole lost at the trial court level. The trial court denied the petition, likening the daily logs to “post-it” notes that were intended to remind the supervisor of events when he prepared the annual performance evaluation. The trial court also pointed out that the parties conceded that if Poole’s supervisor had written Poole’s annual performance evaluation from his memory and not based on written recollections in the daily logs, there would have been no lawsuit. The trial court therefore concluded the daily logs were not part of the personnel file and Poole had no right to respond to the adverse comments. Poole and the union appealed the trial court decision.


On appeal, Poole and his union asked the court to order all adverse comments to be deleted from the daily logs pursuant to a provision of the Firefighters Procedural Bill of Rights Act (FBOR) that provides that adverse comments shall not be entered into a personnel file “or any other file used for any personnel purposes by his or her employer, without the firefighter having first read and signed the instrument containing the adverse comment indicating he or she is aware of the comment . . .” (Gov. Code, § 3255.) Obviously, the purpose of this request is to eliminate the ability of the Fire Authority to rely on these prior acts as a factual basis for the substandard performance evaluation and placement on the improvement plan.


In its review, the Court of Appeal relied heavily on an old California Supreme Court case, Miller v. Chico Unified School District, which interpreted an Education Code section regarding a teacher’s right to review and comment on information of a “derogatory nature” before placed in their personnel file. In Miller v. Chico Unified School District (1979) 24 Cal.3d 703, a school principal had been reassigned to a classroom position after the district’s governing board reviewed 20 (twenty) confidential memoranda prepared by an Associate Superintendent that the principal was unaware of. The California Supreme Court in Miller ultimately ordered the principal to be reinstated to his administrative position because the principal was not provided the opportunity to review or comment on the memoranda even though the district’s governing board made its decision based on these documents.


The Court held that the interpretation of the Education Code in the Miller decision should be applied to sections 3255 and 3256 of the FBOR. It noted that Poole’s supervisor’s daily logs were used for making personnel decisions and affected Poole’s employment status. Poole received a substandard annual performance evaluation and placed on an improvement plan, based upon the information maintained in the daily logs. (This of course discounts any independent recollection the supervisor may have had). The Court concluded that the FBOR was violated because the daily logs were used for personnel purposes. The Court noted that the FBOR’s right to respond to adverse comments that may affect personnel decisions “is frustrated when the firefighter’s supervisor maintains a daily log containing adverse comments that may reach as far back as the day after the firefighter’s last yearly evaluation and the adverse comments are not revealed to the firefighter until the next yearly review, at which point the firefighter may respond to adverse comments in that review.”


On February 26, 2014, the California Supreme Court granted a petition to review the recent Court of Appeal decision. It is important to understand, however, that if the Poole decision is upheld by the California Supreme Court, it will be problematic for school districts because many supervisors rely on informal notes compiled during an evaluation period to complete a thorough and accurate annual evaluation at the end of the year. Such a ruling will: (a) prohibit a supervisor from keeping or maintaining any negative notes or comments or documents regarding an employee unless the employee was provided a prompt opportunity to review and comment upon each separate note or comment; and (b) will require supervisors to start documenting every incident deemed worthy of consideration for inclusion in an evaluation, provide each employee with a separate comment or note and an opportunity to respond to it, and then place all of these documents into their personnel file – which we know employees will not respond well too.


Hopefully, the Supreme Court will conclude that an individual negative note or comment kept in an employee’s pending evaluation file and kept solely for the purposes of aiding in recollection to ensure accuracy in the preparation of the annual evaluation does not trigger a separate due process requirement. In the alternative, we could add “Photographic” or ‘Eidetic” memory to the list of qualifications required for supervisors, if our only alternatives are to prepare evaluations solely from memory or increase our file cabinet budget because of the size our personnel files will need to be now to accommodate the additional documentation the Poole decision may end up requiring be maintained in the personnel file, in addition to the evaluation document that essentially summarizes the same.


Welcome back to the new school year!


Categories: Lawsuits, Leadership

Post a Comment


Oops, you forgot something.


The words you entered did not match the given text. Please try again.


Reply LowellTiept
9:08 PM on August 13, 2022 
Very good information. Cheers. prescription price comparison prescription cost comparison
Reply rupulu
8:16 PM on August 13, 2022 
lakers 2020 championship merch toteme molveno dress supreme x the north face vest under armour black long sleeve
Reply Backpacking And Outdoor Sleeping Bag
7:58 PM on August 13, 2022 
Reply LeroyPic
7:31 PM on August 13, 2022 
You actually reported that terrifically. drugs canada
url= says...
canada pharmacies online pharmacy
national pharmacies
Reply AlvenMus
7:26 PM on August 13, 2022 
Kudos. I enjoy this!
url= says...
mexican online pharmacies
canadian drugs without prescription
Reply RudolphSkync
4:19 PM on August 13, 2022 
Thank you! Great stuff. canadian discount pharmacy
url= says...
fda approved canadian online pharmacies
Reply curry 6 shoes
3:54 PM on August 13, 2022 
I definitely wanted to construct a remark to be able to appreciate you for all the magnificent techniques you are showing at this website. My considerable internet search has finally been compensated with extremely good insight to go over with my contacts. I 'd claim that most of us site visitors actually are really lucky to dwell in a wonderful network with very many perfect people with useful strategies. I feel truly happy to have encountered the web pages and look forward to some more excellent moments reading here. Thank you once more for a lot of things.
curry 6 shoes
Reply cheap kyrie irving shoes
3:53 PM on August 13, 2022 
I actually wanted to jot down a simple note to say thanks to you for all the precious tricks you are sharing at this website. My time-consuming internet lookup has at the end of the day been compensated with sensible knowledge to write about with my pals. I would declare that we site visitors are very much fortunate to live in a superb place with very many wonderful professionals with useful methods. I feel quite privileged to have encountered the web pages and look forward to some more entertaining times reading here. Thank you once again for all the details.
cheap kyrie irving shoes
Reply kevin durant shoes
3:52 PM on August 13, 2022 
Thank you a lot for providing individuals with such a spectacular opportunity to check tips from this website. It is always so fantastic and also stuffed with a great time for me personally and my office acquaintances to visit the blog really 3 times every week to see the latest issues you will have. Not to mention, I'm just actually impressed with your great points you give. Some 2 ideas in this article are in reality the most suitable we have all had.
kevin durant shoes
Reply cheap kd 12
3:51 PM on August 13, 2022 
I just wanted to develop a small message to appreciate you for the pleasant secrets you are giving at this site. My incredibly long internet lookup has now been paid with extremely good knowledge to write about with my visitors. I would say that many of us site visitors are rather endowed to exist in a superb place with so many outstanding people with interesting points. I feel really grateful to have encountered the web pages and look forward to plenty of more thrilling times reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.
cheap kd 12
Reply cheap paul george shoes
3:51 PM on August 13, 2022 
I would like to point out my admiration for your kindness for individuals that must have help with your field. Your very own commitment to passing the solution all around turned out to be wonderfully significant and has without exception empowered guys and women like me to reach their pursuits. Your informative advice implies a whole lot a person like me and far more to my office workers. Best wishes; from each one of us.
cheap paul george shoes
Reply golden goose shoes
3:50 PM on August 13, 2022 
I must show some appreciation to you for bailing me out of this particular scenario. Right after scouting through the online world and coming across techniques which were not pleasant, I thought my entire life was over. Living without the presence of solutions to the problems you have sorted out through your entire guideline is a critical case, as well as the ones that would have adversely affected my entire career if I hadn't discovered your website. Your personal skills and kindness in handling every item was crucial. I am not sure what I would have done if I had not encountered such a subject like this. I can at this time look forward to my future. Thanks a lot so much for this expert and results-oriented help. I will not hesitate to endorse your web blog to anyone who will need tips on this subject matter.
golden goose shoes
Reply LowellTiept
12:57 PM on August 13, 2022 
Kudos! A lot of content!
canadadrugsonline walmart pharmacy price check
Reply AlvenMus
12:48 PM on August 13, 2022 
You stated it fantastically.
url= says...
prescription prices
canadian prescription
Reply longchamp
12:47 PM on August 13, 2022 
I simply wished to say thanks yet again. I am not sure the things I might have created without the recommendations provided by you concerning my topic. It seemed to be a real daunting case for me personally, however , being able to view a professional mode you handled that forced me to jump for joy. Now i'm grateful for the assistance and in addition wish you are aware of a great job that you're undertaking teaching other individuals through the use of your webblog. I am sure you haven't met any of us.
Reply LeroyPic
11:25 AM on August 13, 2022 
Great advice. Many thanks. shoppers drug mart pharmacy
url= says...
online pharmacies without prescription
online medicine to buy
Reply Pcb Assembly Quote
11:23 AM on August 13, 2022 
UL3573 200C 10KV Wire High Voltage Silicone Rubber Cable
Pcb Assembly Quote
Reply Micloxync
10:11 AM on August 13, 2022 
albuterol cost online purchase
Reply RudolphSkync
8:07 AM on August 13, 2022 
Thanks a lot! Numerous postings.
canadadrugs pharmacy on line northwest pharmacy/com
Reply kyrie spongebob
8:07 AM on August 13, 2022 
I want to show appreciation to this writer for bailing me out of such a condition. Right after searching throughout the search engines and getting techniques which are not helpful, I was thinking my life was gone. Living devoid of the solutions to the problems you've solved through your entire website is a serious case, and ones which could have in a wrong way affected my career if I hadn't encountered your web page. Your actual understanding and kindness in dealing with every aspect was important. I am not sure what I would have done if I hadn't come across such a thing like this. I am able to at this time relish my future. Thank you very much for your reliable and amazing help. I will not hesitate to propose your web page to anybody who ought to have recommendations on this topic.
kyrie spongebob